Evaluating In-Network, Cash-Based v. Hybrid Business Models For New PT Clinic Owners

If you’re just starting your private physical therapy business, one of the most important steps is to decide on your business model. There are two primary business models typically used in private practice PT, the traditional in-network insurance model and the cash-based model. Each comes with its own set of advantages and challenges. Let’s explore the benefits and how you can implement the best of both in your clinic.

Comparing In-Network and Cash-Based Services For Your PT Clinic

Choosing the right physical therapy business model is crucial for success and patient satisfaction. Two primary models to consider are the cash-based model and the all in-network model. In order to determine which model is best suited for your clinic, let’s explore the pros and cons of each. 

Advantages of the In-Network Insurance Model


1. Standardized Practice

The in-network insurance model offers a standardized approach to physical therapy services. By participating in insurance networks, your clinic adheres to specific protocols and guidelines set by the insurance companies. This can provide patients with a sense of familiarity and confidence in your clinic’s ability to deliver consistent and reliable care.

2. More Referrals

Being in-network with insurance providers can significantly increase patient referrals. For instance, when a primary care physician recommends physical therapy to a patient, they often refer them to an in-network provider to ensure the patient’s insurance covers the treatment. This steady stream of referrals helps maintain a consistent flow of new patients to your clinic.

3. Increased Accessibility

In-network insurance benefits make it easier for patients to afford treatment, ensuring that more individuals can access the care they need. For example, patients with co-pays or co-insurance often find it more affordable to visit in-network PT clinics than out-of-network providers.

Challenges of the In-Network Insurance Model:


1. Getting Credentialed

The process of getting credentialed with insurance companies can be time-consuming and complex. Clinics must navigate through extensive paperwork, fulfill specific requirements and wait for approval from multiple insurance providers. Delays or denials in the credentialing process can impede a clinic’s ability to accept certain insurance plans, limiting access for potential patients and hindering revenue generation.

2. Low Reimbursement Rates

In-network clinics may face challenges with low reimbursement rates from insurance companies. For instance, the recent 15% payment reduction announced by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services for services provided by physical therapy assistants and occupational therapy assistants can directly impact your clinic’s revenue and profitability.

3. Limited Treatment Options

Insurance providers may impose restrictions on the number of physical therapy sessions or other limitations on treatment. For example, some insurance plans may only cover a certain number of sessions per year, which could hinder the delivery of comprehensive care to patients who require additional treatment.

4. Increased Risk of Burnout

To maintain profitability, in-network clinics may need to treat a higher volume of patients per day. This high patient load can put a strain on physical therapists and support staff, potentially leading to burnout and affecting the overall quality of care.

Benefits of the Cash-Based Model


1. Higher Quality of Care

Cash-based practices offer the advantage of working one-on-one with patients until they achieve full recovery. This individualized attention allows physical therapists to customize treatment plans based on each patient’s unique needs and progress, leading to better patient outcomes.

2. Streamlined Administrative Process

Cash-based practices alleviate the burden of extensive paperwork typically required by insurance providers. Without the need to navigate complex billing procedures and insurance authorization processes, PTs can focus more on providing excellent patient care and spend more time with each patient.

3. Reduced Risk of Burnout

Cash-based models eliminate the pressure of treating a minimum number of patients per hour, allowing physical therapists to dedicate ample time and attention to each patient. This reduced workload can lead to reduced stress and a healthier work-life balance, ultimately minimizing the risk of burnout.

Challenges of the Cash-Based Model


1. Not Ideal for Medicare Patients

Cash-based PT clinics may only accept cash payments from Medicare patients if the treatment falls under statutory exclusion or is deemed medically unnecessary. For instance, non-covered services such as wellness programs or fitness services may be eligible for cash payment. However, accepting cash from Medicare patients for covered services could lead to legal and compliance issues.

2. Higher Marketing Costs

Like out-of-network clinics, cash-based practices need to invest in marketing efforts to convince patients of the superior value of their services. This can entail additional expenses for online marketing, advertising, and community outreach to establish your clinic as a premium provider of specialized care.

3. Limited Accessibility

Cash-based services can be cost-prohibitive for some lower-income individuals. As a cash-based PT clinic, you must carefully consider your location and the affordability of your services within the local community to ensure accessibility for a diverse patient population.

Striking a Happy Medium: Hybrid Payment Models

To find the perfect balance between the in-network insurance model and the cash-based model, many physical therapy clinics are starting to adopt a hybrid payment approach. This innovative strategy allows clinics to leverage the strengths of both models while mitigating their respective limitations. By incorporating a hybrid payment model into your practice, you can provide patients with a more diverse range of payment options, enhance patient satisfaction and optimize your clinic’s revenue streams.

Incorporating Cash-Based Services Into Your PT Clinic

Many physical therapy clinics are recognizing the value of incorporating cash-based services. By providing these specialized services alongside traditional in-network treatments, clinics can cater to a broader range of patient needs and enhance the overall patient experience. 

Cash-based services not only allow clinics to provide personalized care but also present opportunities to explore innovative treatment options and revenue streams. In this section, we will explore a selection of cash-based services that can be seamlessly integrated into your PT clinic, benefiting both your patients and your practice.

1. Weight Loss Programs

Introduce cash-based weight loss programs that incorporate evidence-based exercise regimens and nutritional counseling. For example, you can create personalized weight loss plans for patients struggling with obesity or weight management issues.

2. Nutritional Coaching

Offer cash-based nutritional coaching services to educate patients on healthy eating habits and how proper nutrition can complement their physical therapy treatment. This can include meal planning, dietary assessments, and ongoing support to help patients achieve their health goals.

3. Athletic Performance Training

Provide specialized cash-based training programs for athletes looking to enhance their performance, prevent injuries, and improve recovery. For example, you can offer sports-specific training sessions and exercises tailored to individual athlete needs.

4. Innovative PT Device Systems

Integrate cutting-edge physical therapy device systems like the NEUBIE into your clinic’s offerings. This technology-driven approach can attract tech-savvy patients seeking advanced treatment options and set your clinic apart from competitors.

5. Diagnostic Testing (e.g., HRV Monitoring)

Incorporate cash-based diagnostic testing services, such as heart rate variability (HRV) monitoring, to assess patients’ autonomic nervous system function. This can help identify stress levels and optimize recovery strategies.

Maintaining In-Network Relationships

As your clinic adopts a hybrid payment model, it is essential to strike a delicate balance between incorporating cash-based services and maintaining valuable in-network relationships. Sustaining strong connections with insurance providers can ensure a steady flow of patient referrals and enhance the accessibility of your services to a broader patient population.

Continue to nurture your relationships with insurance providers to receive patient referrals for medical care providers. Consider reaching out to primary care physicians, orthopedic surgeons and other healthcare professionals in your area to inform them about the services your clinic offers.

Maintaining in-network status ensures that patients with specific insurance plans can access your services at a more affordable cost. Continue to accept insurance coverage for medically necessary treatments while offering additional cash-based services to cater to diverse patient needs.

Connect with MEG to Learn More About Embracing a Hybrid Model

By adopting a hybrid approach that combines the strengths of both in-network and cash-based models, your physical therapy clinic can cater to a broader patient base while delivering high-quality, personalized care. Your clinic can stand out as a leading provider in the healthcare industry.

If you’re interested in exploring the benefits of a hybrid payment model for your physical therapy clinic but would like further guidance and support, MEG Business is here to help. As leading PT coaches and PT service providers, MEG has extensive experience in helping clinic owners set up new systems to scale their business. Contact MEG’s team of experts today for a consultation.

MEG Academy - Physical Therapy Business Training

Recent Blogs

Go to Top